Guest Commentary: Common Core Won’t Improve Educational Outcomes

March 12, 2014
Michael Fields

Michael Fields

After the disastrous rollout of Obamacare, you would think that state legislatures would gladly stand up against any kind of perceived takeover by the federal government.

In Colorado, however, this has not been the case. Last month, Colorado Democrats shot down a proposal to delay the implementation of common core standards for a year.

This was a clear example of how liberals in Washington D.C. are constantly reaching for more and more control over states and localities – and the Democrats in Colorado keep rolling out the red carpet for them.

In order to encourage the implementation of common core, the federal government used its usual playbook – dangling money out there for the states to use (don’t forget about our $17 trillion national debt). States were looked upon more favorably for “Race to the Top” funds if they decided to adopt common core standards.

Coercion? Well, this certainly seems to be about as “voluntary” as the Medicaid expansion in Obamacare was found to be by the Supreme Court (hint: not voluntary at all).

The very reason our country was founded on the principle of federalism was so that the states could be the laboratories of democracy. Throughout our history, we have trusted states and localities, and we have been vehemently opposed to having a central government make decisions for everyone on every issue.

We must continue to keep in mind that embracing a market approach to policy is important – and that having a top-down, one-size-fits-all approach to government simply leads to worse outcomes.

Regardless of the problem of federal control, adopting common core does not even guarantee improved educational outcomes.

Just like handing uninsured individuals health insurance cards does not guarantee that they will receive timely quality care, handing schools and teachers new standards doesn’t mean students will actually master them.

There is no doubt that we want accountability, but when we change the standardized testing every few years, how can we possibly know if we are being effective or not?

So, if improving educational outcomes is the ultimate goal, where is the focus?

For the largest teachers union in Colorado, the focus is on opposing the teacher tenure reforms (sponsored by a Democrat) that work to hold teachers accountable. The union is pushing for the forced hiring of tenured teachers that are out of work.

To most reasonable people, it seems like common sense that schools should be able to pick who teaches in their classrooms. If teachers are good, they will have no problem getting hired.

Reforming the teacher tenure laws was a good start, but tenure should be thrown out altogether.  It does nothing to benefit students.

In order for our schools to improve, we must accelerate educational innovation, not stifle it through initiatives like common core. Since no student deserves to be stuck in a failing school or one that does not fit his or her needs, we need to increase choice in education.

Lastly, we need to ensure that more funding actually gets to classrooms instead of growing an already bloated educational bureaucracy.

Michael Fields is a 6th grade teacher at a charter school in Aurora, and a Republican candidate for Colorado House District 37.

Comments made by visitors are not representative of The Colorado Observer staff.

4 Responses to Guest Commentary: Common Core Won’t Improve Educational Outcomes

  1. PeterP
    March 12, 2014 at 3:45 pm

    Oh, I don’t understand all of the hoopla. We just legalized a very child friendly gateway drug. Our schools are run by unions for the safe entrenchment of their members despite their abilities. Our international rankings in educational comparisons continue to drop. Why not let Washington run our classrooms? As long as the Constitution is being ignored and not taught to new generations, they will not know what they are missing. I think the system is not working well enough already. I suppose another “reform” like common core would promote the slide, but we are doing bad enough without it.

  2. Bob Terry
    March 25, 2014 at 2:59 pm

    Yeah, typical liberal agenda, at our expense. Are we educating out children for the benefit of the Union’s, or for the benefit of the Children. The XXX has three or four mommies, climate change, political correctness. No wonder no one can read or write. I understand and I obey robotics. Screw ‘em

    I read at a 4th grade level, when I was young I’m 61 now. How did i do that I was taught. Oh the Polar Bear on the small sheet of ice. Really drowning? then how does he or she survive? By floating. Like grabbing a boxcar on the fly..these small floes are that. Rest and go for the kill, but political correctness, oh they will drown. How did the generations survive without Al Gore and the Liberal agenda… Screw ‘em I’m sick of providing crap education. That includes Denver Boulder and Aurora.

  3. Mischelle M
    April 2, 2014 at 5:38 pm

    Keep pushing to do away with this, in the meantime have removed all kids from public schools I can do better than this garbage.

    • Andrew W
      April 29, 2014 at 2:19 pm

      If you can do better, please do. Work to make education better. But if you join with educators, anyone who wants to do their best for kids, you’ll be hated and mocked by people who don’t have the time to check their facts. You’ll be pressed to be more humane and equitable and inclusive by the left and less expensive and harder working by the right. And no matter how hard you work, you will be seen as a part of the problem, as lazy an inept–because you chose to serve kids. You may be an award-winning teacher who stays awake at night because you care more than anything about Joey’s reading score, but no one will know that. But work to make education better anyway. Kids and learning are essential. Worth so much more than a quick comment or a political rant.

Leave a Reply to Mischelle M Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Complete Colorado
Colorado Peak Politics - Sometimes Unruly. Always Conservative.

Visitor Poll

Should illegal immigrant kids flooding the border be housed in Colorado?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

The Colorado Observer